• Taypedia
  • Posts
  • Our favorite Taylor Swift Etsy shops

Our favorite Taylor Swift Etsy shops

Because we love to support a Swiftie small business ✨

February 26, 2025

Swifties know that the official Taylor Swift merchandise shop can get, well, a little expensive. I had the “All Too Well: 10 Minute Version” poster on my wall in college, and I loved it, but it was pricey. Now I know that I should have looked at options on Etsy.

On Etsy, you can literally shop Swiftie merch till you drop because of how many storefronts are dedicated to Swift. But you should be careful about where you buy from — the scammers will always scam.

Take a look at these seven well-reviewed shops run by talented Swifties who design these unique products for very reasonable prices.

But first…a word from our partner, 1440 Media (psst, every click below helps support Taypedia and keep this newsletter content free!)👇

Daily News for Curious Minds

Be the smartest person in the room by reading 1440! Dive into 1440, where 4 million Americans find their daily, fact-based news fix. We navigate through 100+ sources to deliver a comprehensive roundup from every corner of the internet – politics, global events, business, and culture, all in a quick, 5-minute newsletter. It's completely free and devoid of bias or political influence, ensuring you get the facts straight. Subscribe to 1440 today.

Credit: CrescentCatCo on Etsy

CrescentCatCo is an Etsy-based shop owned by Sarah Martin, who describes her items as “witchy and whimsical.” She mostly sells sweatshirts, T-shirts, and hats — many of which are inspired by folklore and evermore.

Why I love it: I can definitely see why Sarah describes the shop as witchy —she incorporates a lot of moons, castles, and nature symbols into her designs. All of the products are clearly made with love and care. Some items (like the hat pictured above) are embroidered, which reviewers say is extremely well done. Plus, her shop has over two thousand sales and a five-star rating — likely because the items are high quality and she replies to messages quickly.

My favorite item: This blue and gold “seven” inspired sweatshirt. 

Credit: PopCulturePoison on Etsy

PopCulturePoison, owned by Tiffany, sells a variety of beautiful, soft sweatshirts with lyrics and designs on them, as well as tote bags, T-shirts, prints, tumblers, and more. There’s more to explore on her site though, so be sure to check it out.

Why I love it: Tiffany’s designs are unique; some of the sweatshirts feature vintage photographs of women that match the vibe of the lyrics on the item, and others are lyrics surrounding gorgeous botanical designs. I have never seen anything like her work.

My favorite item: Although I love so many of the items, I have to give a nod to this Eras Tour sweatshirt that says “it was rare, I was there” on it. That is just so clever!

Credit: hausofmoods on Etsy

Hausofmoods, owned by Madison Christensen, has five stars because it is considered a “top place to buy gifts,” according to Etsy. Madison sells prints, puzzles, and even a Lover inspired soy candle. 

Why I love it: The print designs (pictured above) are so cool — I can envision them hanging in the living room of a Swiftie’s apartment. You can also purchase the prints as digital downloads to save a few bucks, and then print it to be whatever size you want.

My favorite item: Although I love the prints, I can’t help but say my favorite item is this Eras puzzle — it is the cutest thing ever. A lot of Swift merchandise is wearable, and at a certain point you have to admit that you have enough crewnecks. But that doesn’t mean you should have to stop buying more merchandise! This puzzle is such a fun activity for a Swiftie (or a group of Swifties) to do on a rainy day.

Credit: SpiralBloom on Etsy

SpiralBloom, owned by Sophie, has a focus on cardigan dupes. This shop is another top one for gifts, with over a thousand sales and a five-star rating. Reviewers say the cardigans are warm and well-made.

Why I love it: Although there are a lot of cardigan dupes out there, I think SpiralBloom is one of the best places to buy them. Not only are they quality sweaters that copy the original design, but they have unique touches to them (like this Reputation-inspired cardigan with the snake) and Sophie is said to be extremely reliable.

My favorite item: This blue 1989 cardigan. The eagles flying on the back show that Sophie clearly worked hard to create this!

Credit: ShopNewRomantics on Etsy

ShopNewRomantics is a four-star rated Swiftie shop with a record for smooth shipping. What more can a Swiftie ask for?

Why I love it: ShopNewRomantics doesn’t have as many sales as some of the other shops on this list, but I added it because of the Eras movie tumbler dupes and the blankets. Reviews say that the dupe of the cup (which comes as a tumbler with a straw or an insulated tumbler for iced or hot drinks) is the perfect dupe for the cups that were sold at the movie theater.

My favorite item: My favorite item is definitely the “Wonderland” throw. It’s one of my favorite songs and the “Alice in Wonderland” inspired design on the blanket truly makes it something special.

Credit: LakesandLore on Etsy

LakesandLore is a five star reviewed Etsy shop with speedy shipping and quick replies. The owner, Sam, is known for responding to messages as soon as possible. In addition to designs Swifties would love, Sam also makes a lot of products that Ariana Grande fans and anyone in tune with astrology would love.

Why I love it: Sam says her shop is “where fandom meets fantasy,” which is evident from her designs. A good example: this sweatshirt that has a black cat wearing a witch hat with the lyrics “Karma is a cat” underneath it. If karma is a cat, it’s definitely the one on this sweatshirt.

Sam also runs a lot of sales on her high-quality items, but everything has a very reasonable price tag even when not on sale.

My favorite item: I can’t pick just one! I love this “mirrorball” T-shirt and this Lover butterfly bag.

Credit: NourDesignCo on Etsy

NourDesignCo, owned by Layla, has over a thousand sales, five stars, and a history of speedy shipping. 

Why I love it: My sister actually bought me the bag pictured above, which has “marjorie” lyrics on it, from this shop and I love it so much. It’s really good quality and the exact right size for a tote bag.

My favorite item: Obviously the bag my sister got me! But I love this “Hey Stephen” bag, too. You don’t see a lot of “Hey Stephen” merchandise, do you?

What are your favorite Swiftie-coded Etsy shops? Reply and let us know!